Treatise

ARMORUM Archive Record
Treatise Catalogued Reviewed

Refutation de l'escrime a la baionnette, de M. Gomard

Treatise 1847 French France

Joseph Pinette

Later Joseph Pinette bayonet-fencing family distinct from the earlier Ecole du tirailleur line. Gelli first gives the 1847 anti-Gomard refutation and then a 1848 ninth edition circulating under Traite or Theorie de l'escrime a la baionnette; the family therefore combines polemical and technical states under one later work record.

2 Editions
2 Resources
0 Holdings
3 References
Bibliographic Overview
TitleRefutation de l'escrime a la baionnette, de M. Gomard
AuthorJoseph Pinette
Earliest publication date1847
LanguageFrench
CountryFrance
Document typeTreatise
Authority statement
Joseph Pinette
Bayonet FightingFencing Bayonet
Authority Roles
Author
Joseph Pinette
Edition History
Réfutation de l’escrime à la baïonnette de M. Gomard 1847
CityParis
PublisherJ. Dumaine
PrinterNot specified
Formatin-8
Pages43 p.
DimensionsNot specified
Paris, 1847, J. Dumaine. Gelli gives this as the opening state of the later Pinette bayonet family, framed explicitly as a refutation of Gomard.

Source pages: 260.

Quality phase 101p: duplicate edition 1753 consolidated here after individual review.
Traité de l’escrime à la baïonnette — 9e édition 1848
CityParis
PublisherJ. Dumaine
PrinterNot specified
FormatNot specified
PagesNot specified
DimensionsNot specified
Paris, 1848. Gelli cites this as the ninth edition and notes a small volume with 16 intaglio figures; he also warns that some catalogues replace Traite with Theorie.

Quality phase 101b: publication city recovered from the explicit opening imprint in this note.

Quality phase 421: specialist bibliography identifies the 1848 ninth edition and its sixteen intaglio figures; publisher and pagination remain unresolved.

Quality phase 471: Thimm confirms Paris, J. Dumaine, 1847, for Pinette’s refutation.
Digital Witnesses
Thimm bibliography — phase 471 edition 3581
Catalogue PDF
Thimm bibliography · open
Research witness linked in quality phase 471 (50-edition batch).
Bibliothèque nationale de France — Réfutation de "L'Escrime à la baïonnette" de M. Gomard, par Jh Pinette...
Catalogue HTML
Bibliothèque nationale de France · open
Exact manifestation match located during the complete external research campaign of quality phase 264 (2026-08-25). Catalogue identifier: ark:/12148/cb311148211.

Phase 638 cover audit: the official BnF Catalogue cover API was queried for this exact ARK and returned no available image.

Cover audit phase 719: reviewed in the complete frozen 821-candidate pass. Disposition=catalogue_or_finding_aid. Bibliographic catalogue/finding-aid record; useful for identity, but not itself an edition image source. External probe: HTTP 503; content type text/html; charset=iso-8859-1.

Cover audit phase 740: final outcome=no_image_catalogue_only; bibliographic catalogue or finding-aid record; retained for authority control, but it does not expose a reusable manifestation image.
Scholarly References
Gelli entry GEL-P451-E003
Gelli (1890)
Jacopo Gelli, Bibliografia generale della scherma con note critiche, biografiche e storiche.
Pages 451 · Entry GEL-P451-E003
Gelli entry GEL-P451-E004
Gelli (1890)
Jacopo Gelli, Bibliografia generale della scherma con note critiche, biografiche e storiche.
Pages 451 · Entry GEL-P451-E004
Thimm entry 1694
Thimm (1896)
Carl A. Thimm, A Complete Bibliography of Fencing and Duelling.
Pages 260 · Entry 1694