Treatise

ARMORUM Archive Record
Treatise Catalogued Reviewed

Réflexions techniques et historiques sur l’escrime

Treatise 1874 French France

Adolphe Terwangne

T-block staging entry validated for model fit. Imported from staging batch duell-thimm-t, source entry 2119.

Vigeant 1882 resolves this former shell as the Lille 1874 pamphlet Reflexions techniques et historiques sur l'escrime, issued under the signature of an ancien amateur.

Gelli reports a Lille 1871 witness; Thimm and Vigeant record 1874, and Thimm also notes an 1891 edition. All are retained in one work family.

2 Editions
2 Resources
0 Holdings
3 References
Bibliographic Overview
TitleRéflexions techniques et historiques sur l’escrime
AuthorAdolphe Terwangne
Earliest publication date1874
LanguageFrench
CountryFrance
Document typeTreatise
Authority statement
Adolphe Terwangne
Fencing
Authority Roles
Author
Adolphe Terwangne
Edition History
Reflexions techniques et historiques sur l'escrime 1874
CityLille
PublisherImprimerie Mérieaux
PrinterNot specified
Format8°
PagesIn-8° , 39 p.
DimensionsNot specified
Source pages: 330. Bracketed notes: ["Anotheredition. 12°. 1891. Lille. (39 pages.)"]

Vigeant 1882, p. 125: Lille, Imprimerie Meriaux, 1874. In-8 pamphlet. Signed by an ancien amateur.

Quality phase 101k extent decision: the 39-page value describes an 1891 manifestation, not this 1874 record; pages intentionally left unset.
Réflexions techniques et historiques sur l’escrime 1891
CityLille
PublisherNot specified
PrinterImprimerie Mérieaux
Format12°
Pages39 p.
DimensionsNot specified
Lille, 1891, imprimerie Meriaux. Gelli records the work under the heading Terwangne as written by an ancien amateur.

Quality phase 101k: production/publication place recovered from an explicit, manifestation-matching statement after individual review.

Quality phase 101m: explicit imprint agent linked after final individual review.

Quality phase 421: BnF/Hachette corrects the year from 1871 to 1891; Thimm confirms 39 pages and duodecimo format.
Digital Witnesses
BnF/Hachette — Réflexions techniques et historiques sur l’escrime
Catalogue HTML OCR
BnF / Hachette · open
Exact research witness linked in quality phase 421.

Cover audit phase 719: reviewed in the complete frozen 821-candidate pass. Disposition=page_image_candidate. The page exposes an image candidate; exact-edition visual inspection is required before reuse. External probe: HTTP 206; content type text/html.

Cover audit phase 740: final outcome=page_image_not_reliable_or_not_exact; page imagery reviewed but was generic, a modern reprint, secondary, unstable, or not demonstrably the exact manifestation.
Bibliothèque nationale de France — Réflexions techniques et historiques sur l'escrime par un ancien amateur [A. Terwangne]
Catalogue HTML
Bibliothèque nationale de France · open
Exact manifestation match located during the complete external research campaign of quality phase 264 (2026-08-25). Catalogue identifier: ark:/12148/cb31445870m.

Phase 638 cover audit: the official BnF Catalogue cover API was queried for this exact ARK and returned no available image.

Cover audit phase 719: reviewed in the complete frozen 821-candidate pass. Disposition=catalogue_or_finding_aid. Bibliographic catalogue/finding-aid record; useful for identity, but not itself an edition image source. External probe: HTTP 429; content type text/html; charset=iso-8859-1.

Cover audit phase 740: final outcome=no_image_catalogue_only; bibliographic catalogue or finding-aid record; retained for authority control, but it does not expose a reusable manifestation image.
Scholarly References
Gelli entry GEL-P483-E001
Gelli (1890)
Jacopo Gelli, Bibliografia generale della scherma con note critiche, biografiche e storiche.
Pages 483 · Entry GEL-P483-E001
Thimm entry 2143
Thimm (1896)
Carl A. Thimm, A Complete Bibliography of Fencing and Duelling.
Pages 330 · Entry 2143
Vigeant entry VIG-P125-E002
Vigeant (1882)
Arsène Vigeant, La Bibliographie de l'escrime ancienne et moderne. Paris: Imprimé par Motteroz, 1882.
Pages 125 · Entry VIG-P125-E002